CIRCLEVILLE, Ohio – The trial is underway for a Pickaway County mother and son facing involuntary manslaughter and multiple felony charges in connection with a deadly pit bull attack that claimed the life of a 73-year-old woman and her dog.

Susan Withers, 61, and her son, Adam Withers, 35, appeared in court Monday as opening statements were delivered, marking the beginning of a trial that prosecutors warn will contain graphic evidence, including autopsy photos and police body camera footage.

Jury Selection Issues Delay Proceedings

The morning session was initially delayed due to difficulties seating a full jury panel. According to ABC6, several potential jurors failed to appear for duty, prompting law enforcement officers to visit their homes in an attempt to resolve the issue. Once the full panel was seated, the prosecution and defense laid out their arguments before the court.

Case Background

The case stems from a violent attack in October when a pit bull owned by the Withers family fatally mauled Jo Echelbarger, 73, along with her dog. The incident led to a criminal investigation into the owners’ handling of their animals and whether negligence played a role in the deadly encounter.

Prosecutors argue that the Withers failed to secure their dogs, allowing them to escape and cause fatal harm. They also allege that the family’s condo door did not properly close, which may have contributed to the dogs getting loose.

Defense Pushes Back

Susan Withers’ attorney, Lisa Tome, pushed back against the prosecution’s claims during opening statements, arguing that her client was not even home when the dogs escaped. Tome stated that Adam Withers had driven his mother to work early that morning, implying that she had no direct involvement in the events that led to the attack.

What Comes Next

With testimony set to begin, prosecutors plan to introduce graphic evidence, including autopsy photos and police body camera footage, to illustrate the severity of the attack. Key witnesses, including law enforcement officers and animal control experts, are expected to testify about the conditions of the Withers’ property and whether prior complaints about their dogs had been made.

If convicted, Susan and Adam Withers could face significant prison time for their alleged role in the tragedy.

The case continues this week as the prosecution begins calling its first witnesses.