HILLSBORO, Ohio — Two Florida men have been sentenced to a year in prison after pleading guilty to running a courier scam that cost a Highland County resident nearly $19,000, the Highland County Sheriff’s Office said.
Leon Raynard Brown and Cecil Silvester Arnold, both of Locka, Florida, pleaded guilty Nov. 5 in Highland County Common Pleas Court to third-degree felony aggravated theft from a person in a protected class by deception, according to the sheriff’s office. Each was sentenced to 12 months in prison and ordered to pay restitution.
The investigation began Dec. 1, 2025, when deputies responded to a residence in Brushcreek Township after the victim reported being scammed by people posing as representatives of First State Bank’s fraud department, the sheriff’s office said.
Investigators said the victim was told his bank accounts had been compromised and was instructed to withdraw cash to protect it. He withdrew a total of $19,000 from banks in Winchester and Hillsboro after being told a federal agent would come to his home to collect the money, according to the release.
On Nov. 27, 2025, someone arrived at the victim’s residence in a black Toyota SUV and picked up the cash, the sheriff’s office said. Investigators said they traced the driver, who had unknowingly been hired to transport the money believing it was a legitimate delivery job. Vehicle video, hotel records, airline records and airport surveillance footage, along with help from the Milford Police Department, CVG Airport and the Hamilton County Heroin Task Force, led investigators to identify Brown and Arnold as the suspects, according to the sheriff’s office.
A Highland County grand jury indicted both men, who were extradited from Florida to face the charges, the sheriff’s office said.
Similar cash-pickup scams have targeted other residents in the region, including a Greenfield case in which police arrested a man accused of swindling an elderly resident out of tens of thousands of dollars.
The sheriff’s office reminded residents that financial institutions and government agencies will never ask customers to withdraw large sums of cash and hand it to a stranger or buy gift cards to resolve fraudulent account activity. Anyone who receives such a request should stop communicating immediately and contact their financial institution directly, the office said.
The information contained in this story was obtained from the Highland County Sheriff’s Office.





