Best New York Sports Betting Sites 2025: Top NY Sportsbooks

With legendary teams like the Yankees, the Mets, and the Giants, New Yorkers are easily some of the most passionate fans in the world. And where there’s passion, there’s action — that’s why the best New York sports betting sites step up to deliver top odds and countless markets.

One site that stands above the rest is BetAnySports, the go-to sportsbook for NY bettors, boasting 30+ sports categories and up to a $150 welcome bonus.

Now, let’s dive into the New York sports betting scene and showcase nine other online sportsbooks that deserve a spot on your radar. Here we go!

Heads up about our links! Adblock might get confused so please disable it if you have any issues.

Before you pick a site, check out what the top 5 NY online sportsbooks have to offer in our in-depth reviews down below.

1. BetAnySports – Best New York Sports Betting Site Overall

Pros:

Offshore & American lines
Premier horse racing coverage
Less juice bonuses available
Crisp, mobile-friendly website
$150 welcome bonus

Cons:

Smaller match percentage on welcome offer
Must sign in to see the odds

BetAnySports is the best NY sports betting site, and it’s become renowned for its gambling markets and variety of features. Let’s check out what else it has to offer.

Quality of Odds & Markets: 4.95/5

When it comes to horse racing options, BetAnySports is one of the top options for New York sports betting fans. The platform delivers competitive odds and the widest range of racetracks around – over 50!

The college sports markets are also solid, but overall, the rest of the platform mainly leans towards popular leagues and sports like the NBA, NFL, MLB, and NHL.

So if you’re not into exploring niche markets, BetAnySport’s coverage should be more than adequate for your betting needs.

Bonuses and Promotions: 4.95/5

Newbies are eligible for a great welcome offer at BetAnySports: a 150% match bonus on a deposit of up to $100 with just a 10x rollover.

If that doesn’t sound too appealing, you can grab other different types of promos. There’s a 25% cash rebate bonus, but NY bettors looking to squeeze more value from their wagers can enjoy the less juice offer that grants better odds, meaning that you can cash out more.

Aside from those, you can also get up to $5,000 when you make your 7th deposit on the site, and there’s also a referral bonus.

Payment Methods and Payout Times: 4.9/5

To deposit funds at BetAnySports, you can use MasterCard and Visa credit cards, debit cards, or cryptos such as Bitcoin and Litecoin – with much lower fees associated with digital currencies.

Also, crypto payouts are processed quickly – in a few hours in most instances.

Mobile Betting & Customer Support: 5/5

The platform runs nicely on all device types, which means you can enjoy a mobile gambling experience on all iOS and Android smartphones and tablets without needing to download an app.

If you need help, feel free to reach out through the BetAnySports live chat, phone, or email at any time; all contact information is easily accessible, along with helpful guides on sports betting, plus social media presence on major platforms.

>> Claim up to $150 on your first deposit [BetAnySports]

2. Mystake – Best Betting Variety of Any New York Online Sportsbook

Pros:

40+ sports to bet on
Competitive odds in major US leagues
Excellent eSports coverage
Dedicated Discord group for transparency
120% up to $600 welcome bonus

Cons:

Cluttered design
Hard to find phone support contact info

Mystake has everything it takes to become the best online bookie in New York, from loads of markets through generous bonuses to excellent mobile sports wagering optimization.

Quality of Odds & Markets: 5/5

Mystake’s selection of sports betting options is impressive, particularly in the Big 4 US sports leagues.

The platform offers bets on titles like NBA, NHL, NFL, and MLB and heaps of options for popular video games like Dota 2 and Counter-Strike.

There are over 40 sports to bet on, with top-notch odds throughout. And that’s still not all – Mystake also hosts an amazing collection of over 3,500 casino games. Diversity all the way!

Bonuses and Promotions: 4.95/5

New users enjoy a great bonus at Mystake – the sign-up offer guarantees up to $600 as part of a 120% deposit match! Plus, there is a bonus exclusive for eSports betting too!

Regular players can benefit from 10% cashback on losing days, but the standout promotion for us is the loyalty program.

Unlike most betting sites, Mystake signs you up for their VIP program automatically. You’ll get points with every bet, unlocking special rewards and bonuses. The more you bet, the more perks you qualify for!

Payment Methods and Payout Times: 4.9/5

Mystake offers traditional banking methods such as cards or bank transfers alongside cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin for deposits and withdrawals, making it easy to manage your funds quickly and securely.

Crypto withdrawals are usually processed within hours or even minutes after requested.

Mobile Betting & Customer Support: 4.95/5

The Mystake platform has a well-organized design that looks fantastic on desktop devices and mobile phones, making this site perfect for mobile sports betting lovers!

Furthermore, the customer support team is always ready to assist its users with any queries via live chat or email; the agents work around the clock, so support can come quickly when needed.

>> Get a $600 welcome bonus [Mystake]

3. BetOnline – Best NY Sports Betting Site for NFL Odds & Markets

Pros:

Premier NFL odds and markets
Excellent mobile site
25+ years online
$250 free bet welcome offer
On-site odds boost

Cons:

High fees for credit card users
Fewer reload bonuses overall

For NFL wagering in New York, visit BetOnline. The odds are excellent, and the navigation is super-smooth!

Quality of Odds & Markets: 4.9/5

BetOnline’s NFL options are excellent! With various wager types like straight and parlay bets, many props and teasers, and live betting, there’s always something exciting to bet on.

Plus, there’s the site’s special Odds Booster — you’ll never run out of ways to customize your strategy or find great value.

Bonuses and Promotions: 4.85/5

New folks at BetOnline can get up to $250 in free bets when they join, as well as 100 free spins for online casino games.

Sure, it’s a smaller offer, but it comes with one significant perk: winnings from the free bet have no wagering requirements. So you can withdraw them immediately or use them to place other wagers on the site.

Regular offers are pretty light, but you can still score odds boosts and participate in sports-themed betting tournaments.

Payment Methods and Payout Times: 4.85/5

Depositing money and withdrawing is fast and easy here. Just note that credit card transactions may incur high fees.

Cryptocurrency payments such as Ethereum, Bitcoin, and Litecoin are all fee-free, which is excellent news for anyone who wants to use them!

Mobile Betting & Customer Support: 4.8/5

You don’t need to download apps to bet on BetOnline; just open the site on any device with an internet connection for instant play access. Plus, customer service is always there whenever you need it – they’re available 24/7, so you never have to feel lost or stuck without help!

>> Get $250 in free bets at BetOnline

4. BetWhale – Best Crypto Sports Betting Site in New York

Pros:

150% deposit boost for newcomers
Tens of thousands of daily sports markets
Crypto payouts delivered in a few hours
Built-in parlay builder
30+ sports categories

Cons:

$150 minimum withdrawal limit
No live chat support

If you have some crypto lying around and want to spend it on sports wagers, head to BetWhale which offers some of the fastest payouts in the industry.

Quality of Odds & Markets: 4.8/5

No matter the sport, BetWhale has you covered with a good selection of daily betting options, offering over 30,000 choices. Whether you’re interested in NFL spreads, NHL moneylines, golf matchups, parlays, props, or any other type of wager, the site delivers.

The odds are competitive, helping you maximize your potential returns on each bet. The platform also makes placing complex wagers easy with a user-friendly bet slip and an integrated parlay feature, streamlining the process for bettors of all levels.

Bonuses and Promotions: 4.7/5

New customers at BetWhale will get a 150% deposit boost. This offer is great because it covers both casino games and sports betting options.

Since we’re talking about sportsbooks, you will get a 125% match up to $1,250 when you make the first qualifying deposit of $50 or more and use the code THEBOOST.

This welcome package has 10x wagering requirements and no cashout limits, so make sure you take advantage of that.

Payment Methods and Payout Times: 4.8/5

Payment options at BetWhale include credit cards, debit cards (Visa, Mastercard, etc.), Bitcoin deposits, PayPal, bank wires, and multiple altcoins.

For example, you can use Solana (SOL), which many New York sports betting platforms do not support.

Most deposits go through almost instantaneously – digital currencies are confirmed within a few minutes of submitted requests. Withdrawals take 2-5 business days, depending on the selected method.

Interestingly enough, digital currency offers near-instant payouts, so you can get your winnings immediately!

Mobile Betting & Customer Support: 4.75/5

If you’re looking to place some wagers on the go, BetWhale’s mobile experience is second to none, letting users access the same range of markets they would find on desktop versions via any device’s browser.

Moreover, should you need assistance, there’s no need to worry, as customer service reps are always available through the phone number. However, we couldn’t find a live chat option.

>> Score a 150% deposit boost at BetWhale

5. MyBookie – Best New York Sportsbook for NBA Betting

Pros:

Top-notch NBA markets
Hundreds of props on individual NBA games
$1,000 welcome bonus
Unique prop builder tool
Over 50 tracks for horse racing betting

Cons:

Dated design
Not the widest banking variety

Last but not least in our top 5 reviews is Mybookie, which also ranks as one of the leading online betting sites in Texas. If you want to spice things up as an NBA fan, MyBookie is the NY sportsbook to join.

Quality of Odds & Markets: 4.8/5

MyBookie is a great source for your betting needs. You’ll find plenty of props to choose from in single matches. NBA markets, for example, are awesome! Very few sites can boast 200+ props available on a single NBA game, right?

The site’s college sports coverage is also solid, and we like how they include multiple horse racetracks around the globe – even Swedish tracks!

Bonuses and Promotions: 4.75/5

Other boosts include the 50% Reload Bonus and the 200% Refer-a-Friend promo. Keep an eye out on their promotions page, too, as they offer additional goodies.

Payment Methods and Payout Times: 4.75/5

At MyBookie, New York bettors can pay with Visa and MasterCard credit, debit cards, or MoneyGram.

Alternatively, you can switch over to crypto – Bitcoin (BTC), Litecoin (LTC), Ethereum (ETH), and XRP for the lowest fees when cashing out. The funds should arrive in your wallet within hours after the withdrawal is complete.

The selection is solid, nothing out of the ordinary, but it still covers the majority of users in terms of banking preference.

Mobile Betting & Customer Support: 4.65/5

The web-based MyBookie platform allows you to easily bet whenever you want, wherever you want, though it might need some revamping given its dated looks. Customer service is available 24/7 via live chat or email if you have any queries about the platform!

How We Ranked the Best NY Sports Betting Sites

Odds & Betting Markets

Sports bettors in New York have access to some of the most competitive betting markets and online odds. The selection covers all major sports leagues and tournaments and several minor ones. In addition to offering lines on hundreds of games, many online bookmakers offer futures and prop bets for even more wagering opportunities like daily fantasy sports.

Bonuses & Promotions

Bonuses make betting even more fun. We looked at each operator’s bonus terms and conditions to ensure they were fair and achievable. Some operators may offer bonuses with higher maximum values, but if their wagering requirements are unrealistic, it wouldn’t be worth taking advantage of them.

Payment Methods & Payout Times

It’s important that customers can trust the payment process when they’re gambling online. That’s why we looked at each operator’s payment methods to ensure a wide range, including popular options like credit card payments, bank transfers, eWallets, and cryptocurrency.

Mobile Betting & Customer Support

We considered every operator’s mobile betting offerings to ensure all New York users could access high-quality offers on all devices. We also looked at customer service teams to ensure that help is available 24/7 in case of any issues or questions.

Why Is BetAnySports the Best Online Sportsbook in New York?

BetAnySports is a top-tier sports betting platform and one of the best gambling sites available to NY punters. Here are a few reasons it should be your sportsbook of choice.

Over 30 Sports Categories: BetAnySports covers all major sports plus many less-known leagues with top-notch market depth. Whatever sport you want to bet on, this NY bookie will have it covered.
$150 Welcome Bonus: BetAnySports offers newcomers $150 in free bets, which you can use to explore the platform and its features. There are also other reload offers and even a less juice bonus that guarantees you better odds.
Extensive Horse Racing Options: BetAnySports goes beyond sports betting with a strong focus on horse racing. From major tracks to international events, this NY sportsbook offers plenty of betting opportunities for racing fans.

Why Should I Use New York Online Sportsbooks?

Just like online betting in Florida and placing wagers in states like Missouri, wagering with NY online sportsbooks has perks over traditional retail betting locations.

Here are four examples of how betting with an online sportsbook in New York can help you get an edge on the competition:

In-Depth Statistics: Many NY online sportsbooks go beyond the typical statistics found on most sites, delivering comprehensive information and analytics to give bettors an in-depth understanding of the teams, players, or games they’re betting on. This kind of data-driven insight can be helpful in predicting outcomes and making smarter wagers.

Odds Comparison Tools: With odds comparison tools available on some sites, users can quickly compare lines across online sportsbooks to find the most advantageous markets and bets. Using these tools, bettors can ensure they get the best value from their wagers.

Exclusive Specials / Promos: Online sports betting sites in New York often offer exclusive promotions that provide extra rewards and bonuses for loyal customers. Look out for promotional offers like enhanced odds or price-per-head specials, which could make all the difference when placing your bets.

Networking Opportunities: Some of the best gambling sites feature forums where members can discuss strategies and share tips for successful betting. The insight gained from interacting with other experienced bettors could be invaluable when placing wagers wisely.

What Are the Most Popular New York Sports Teams To Bet On?

Plenty of exciting betting options are available across all sports, from the NBA’s Knicks and the NHL’s Rangers to MLB’s Yankees and the NFL’s Jets. Here’s a rundown of some of the top teams from around the state:

NBA – New York Knicks: The New York Knicks are one of the most iconic basketball teams in the world. They have an extensive history of over 50 years and boast some of the greatest players ever to lace up sneakers. The team is perennially competitive, making them a go-to choice for New York sports bettors looking to put money down on their favorite team.

NHL – New York Rangers: The New York Rangers are another iconic franchise that has been around since 1926, featuring outstanding players. They’ve had great success throughout their history, winning four Stanley Cups since 1940.

MLB – New York Yankees: The iconic pinstripes donned by baseball’s famous franchise have become synonymous with excellence over their long history dating back to 1903; this makes the Yankees one of the most popular choices for wagers among baseball fans everywhere. With numerous World Series championships, people love betting on games featuring this star-studded team from upstate.

NFL – New York Jets: The Jets may not be as successful as some of their other counterparts from around town, but they are still immensely popular among football fans throughout New Jersey and beyond. The combination of star quarterback Sam Darnold and rising coach Adam Gase should give diehard fans plenty of optimism when placing wagers on games featuring this beloved team.

New York Sports Betting – FAQs

What Is the Best New York Sports Betting Site?

BetAnySports is the best New York sports betting site overall, beating all competing sports betting apps with exceptional market coverage and a $500 sign-up offer.

Are Payment Methods Used by NY Online Sportsbooks Secure?

Payment methods used by New York sports betting sites on this list are highly secure.

All transactions on these sites are encrypted through the highest security protocols, ensuring your sensitive information is kept safe and secure while you make deposits and withdrawals.

Additionally, all payments processed by these online sportsbooks adhere to the Payment Card Industry Data Security Standard (PCI DSS). This means that all financial transactions are monitored closely to keep users’ accounts and funds protected.

All financial data is stored within highly secure servers that meet stringent data protection standards.

As such, online sports bettors in New York can rest assured knowing that their payment methods are extremely safe and secure when using a reputable NY-based online sportsbook.

How Do I Cashout Betting Winnings From New York Online Sportsbooks?

If you’re new to sports betting, you may wonder how to withdraw your winnings from one of these sites. Here is a step-by-step guide to doing it hassle-free:

Log into your account on the online sportsbook.
Navigate to the “Withdrawal” section of the website.
Select your desired withdrawal method (credit/debit card, crypto).
Enter your banking information (if applicable) and specify the amount you wish to withdraw.
Confirm that all details are accurate and submit your withdrawal request.
Depending on the method chosen, funds should be available within 1-5 business days after being approved by the site’s security team.

Are New York Sports Betting Sites Safe?

Yes! All New York sports betting sites in this guide operate under strict regulations that ensure a safe and secure environment for bettors.

If you use one of these regulated, SSL-encrypted sites, you can rest assured that your personal information, deposits, and winnings are protected.

Comparing the 5 Best NY Sportsbooks Online

Here’s a brief summary of the top 5 best online betting sites for New Yorkers and what bettors can expect from each bookie:

BetAnySports: This is the top option on the NY sports betting market for betting online. The welcome bonus is also great, going up to $150!

Mystake: If you love betting on niche sports, Mystake is the best New York online sportsbook for overall market variety. We are looking at over 40 categories for sports wagers, plus a 120% match first deposit bonus going up to $600.

BetOnline: Love football? BetOnline ranks as NY’s best online betting site for betting on the NFL. You’ll get the best odds, exclusive NFL deals, an odds booster, and $250 in free bets when you join.

BetWhale: This is the best NY sports betting app for cryptocurrency enthusiasts, offering tens of thousands of markets per day and a generous 150% deposit boost for all newcomers.

MyBookie: For basketball fans, the top place to bet on the New York Knicks — or the NBA in general — is at Mybookie! This NY sportsbook welcomes all new customers aboard with a $1,000 sign-up deal at a 50% match rate.

How to Join a New York Sports Betting Site and Bet Online

To join an online sports betting site in New York, just follow the step-by-step guide below. The rundown uses BetAnySports as an example, but it’s perfectly valid for all sports betting operators in New York.

1. Register Your Sports Betting Account

Head over to BetAnySport’s homepage.
Click the Sign-Up button.
Fill out the registration form.

2. Verify Your Email

The bookie will send you a verification email.
Click the verification link.
Log in to your new sports betting account.

3. Make a Deposit and Claim the Welcome Bonus

Enter the cashier section.
Set your payment preference and deposit $20 or more to your sports betting account.
Get $150 in free bets.

4. Place Bets Online

Click the Sports tab in the top menu.
Find the sports betting markets you want using the menu on the left.
Find the match – or matches – you are interested in and set your sports wagering details.
Place bets – enjoy!

Tips for Online Sports Betting in New York

Whether you’re betting in Maryland, gambling in New York, or even playing at casinos in California, there are several ways to sharpen your strategy and gain an edge over the bookie.

If you want to take your online sports betting to the next level, here are a few key tactics to consider.

Maximize Value With Line Shopping

Line shopping involves checking out the best casino apps for sports betting to look for lines that favor particular betting styles. For example, if you’re an experienced bettor confident about picking underdogs, it might be worth shopping around for sites offering better odds or prices on those teams. This strategy can help increase your ROI in the long run.

Take Advantage of Arbitrage Betting

Arbitrage betting is a way to place bets simultaneously across multiple online sports betting platforms to make a guaranteed profit no matter which team wins the game. It involves taking advantage of operator odds differences by placing multiple wagers at different bookmakers while covering all possible outcomes. This strategy requires significant research and dedication but can be highly rewarding.

Make Use of Live Streaming and In-game Betting Options

Many online sportsbooks now offer live streaming options, allowing bettors to watch games for free as long as they have placed bets with the operator during that game. Experienced bettors should also look into in-game betting options, allowing them to make in-play bets while the game continues. This type of betting will enable bettors to identify trends or weaknesses mid-game that could give them an edge when placing their wagers.

Join More Than One Online Sports Betting Site

It can be a good idea to join multiple sportsbooks. This will allow you to take advantage of various welcome bonus offers from the numerous operators, giving you more resources to use when placing wagers.

Ready to Join the Best New York Online Sports Betting Sites?

No more chit-chat — let’s get to the betting!

If you’re looking for a solid sportsbook, BetAnySports is a safe bet (pun intended) and should have something for every NY bettor.

You can claim the site’s $500 welcome offer now and give it a go, or take a more in-depth look at other bookies in this guide.

Whatever you choose, bet responsibly and have fun!

DISCLAIMER: The information on this site is for entertainment purposes only. Gambling comes with its fair share of risks and it’s important to recognize that when using online gambling sites.

While we review different gambling sites, you should check with local laws in your area before gambling online. Also, all gambling sites and guides are rated 18+ only.

If you have a gambling addiction problem or anyone you know does, call the National Gambling Helpline at 1-800-522-4700. In addition, the following free gambling addiction resources can be of help:

2025’s Best New York Sports Betting Sites: Top Online Sportsbooks in NY, Ranked By Experts