On October 4th, 2025, Chillicothe police responded to a series of incidents ranging from criminal trespassing and theft to domestic violence and non-criminal calls. Officers conducted multiple investigations, made several arrests, issued traffic citations, and assisted with warrant services and mental health-related calls. Below is a summary of the day’s incidents.
Suspicious Activity at McArthur Gardens
Case Number: PD-P2505113
On October 4th, officers were dispatched to 1049 Columbus St. in relation to a non-criminal matter at McArthur Gardens. The investigation is ongoing.
Traffic Violations on North Bridge Street
Case Number: PD-P2505114
Police responded to a traffic offense involving driving across continuous lines and driving under suspension on North Bridge Street. The incident took place at 3:28 a.m.
Warrant Transfer at Gas Station
Case Number: PD-P2505115
At 8:50 a.m., officers met the Pike County Sheriff’s Office at Izzy’s Gas Station on North Paint St. to accept custody of a detainee. The investigation is ongoing.
Suicidal Person Reported on East Water Street
Case Number: PD-P2505116
Police responded to a call involving a suicidal female near 45 East Water Street. Officers are continuing their investigation.
Arrest Made in Trespassing Behind Business
Case Number: PD-P2505117
At 2:54 p.m., officers responded to reports of a possible altercation behind Rent-2-Own at 1653 North Bridge Street. One individual was arrested for criminal trespass.
Crash Leads to Hit-Skip Investigation
Case Number: PD-P2505118
Police were dispatched to the area of Orange Street and Erie Street following a vehicle crash. The case is being investigated as a hit-skip.
Speed Citation Issued on South Bridge Street
Case Number: PD-P2505119
At 5:22 p.m., an officer issued a traffic citation for speeding on South Bridge Street.
Disorderly Conduct at Courthouse
Case Number: PD-P2505121
Police responded to a disturbance involving a male outside the Common Pleas Court on North Paint Street. The investigation is ongoing.
Vehicle Stolen from Kroger Parking Lot
Case Number: PD-P2505122
A stolen vehicle was reported at the Kroger store located at 887 North Bridge Street. Police are continuing the investigation.
Warrant Service on North Paint Street
Case Number: PD-P2505120
Police met with Commercial Point PD to take custody of Salena Mitchell, who was wanted for failure to appear. She was transported to jail pending a court appearance on October 6.
Trespass Reported on Warner Avenue
Case Number: PD-P2505123
Officers responded to a criminal trespass complaint at 32 Warner Avenue in the evening hours.
Domestic Violence and Menacing on N. Brownell
Case Number: PD-P2505124
At 6:50 p.m., officers responded to a domestic incident at 94 North Brownell Street involving a female who alleged her boyfriend pointed a gun at her. One arrest was made.
Crash Investigated at North High and West Water
Case Number: PD-P2505125
Police responded to a crash at the intersection of North High and West Water Street. The investigation is ongoing.
Falsification and Warrant at Hampton Inn
Case Number: PD-P2505127
At 8:28 p.m., officers were called to the Hampton Inn at 100 Plaza Drive regarding a male subject, resulting in an investigation into falsification and a warrant.
License Plate Violation Leads to Citation
Case Number: PD-P2505126
At 9:05 p.m., a traffic citation was issued for an obstructed license plate.
Disorderly Conduct on Washington Avenue
Case Number: PD-P2505128
Late in the evening, officers responded to 843 Washington Avenue for a report of possible threats. The situation remains under investigation.